MurdokuCase Files
English
Official game

Murdoku case 36

A Messy Situation

  • Hard
  • 9 × 9 grid
  • 8 suspects

Clue cards

  • Abigail

    She was alone.

  • Ben

    He was southeast of Abigail and northwest of Hawa

  • Carl

    He was on a mud puddle.

  • David

    He was alone with Carl.

  • Edgar

    He was beside a tree.

  • France

    She was on a mud puddle.

  • Grace

    She was sitting in a chair. She was exactly one row north of France.

  • Hawa

    She was not beside a table.

  • ValentinoVictim

    The Victim. He was alone with the murderer.

Crime scene

A Messy Situation, 9 columns and 9 rows, Unsolved board from the official game
Unsolved board from the official game

Map objects

  • Tree
  • Table
  • Chair
Opening hint A place to start

Use the occupancy rule to separate the two pairs from the people who have to be alone.

Show walkthrough Includes placements

Coordinates read row first, then column. R1C1 is the top-left square. The deduction steps use the clue-card letters.

  1. Nine people fill seven occupied areas. C and D share one area, and V shares another with the murderer. The other five people must be alone.
  2. G is one row north of F. If G were in the Restroom in row 3, F would use the Kitchen's last row. G must sit in the Living Room while F uses the Porch mud. Cross out R6C1, R7C3, and R8C6.
  3. C needs mud and company from D. The Restroom would block the Kitchen, and G needs the Living Room to herself. Place C at R1C4 and D at R2C7 in the Back Yard. E goes at R9C9.
  4. The Kitchen and Restroom use rows 3 and 4. A is northwest of B and B is northwest of H. This puts A at R3C2 in the Kitchen and B at R4C6 in the Restroom.
  5. H takes R6C8 in the Bedroom, so G goes at R7C1 and F at R8C3. V takes R5C5 in the Living Room.
A Messy Situation, 9 columns and 9 rows, Partial placements in the official game
Partial placements in the official game
A Messy Situation, 9 columns and 9 rows, final placements
All placements in the official game
Reveal the answer Murderer and final grid

Murderer Grace (G) R7C1

Valentino is at R5C5 and shares Living Room with only Grace.

A Messy Situation, 9 columns and 9 rows, final placements
Final placements
IDPersonSquare
AAbigailR3C2
BBenR4C6
CCarlR1C4
DDavidR2C7
EEdgarR9C9
FFranceR8C3
GGraceR7C1
HHawaR6C8
VValentinoR5C5